Recap
3 min read

Columbus Blue Jackets' Early Surge Stalls as Penguins Prevail in Overtime

The Columbus Blue Jackets faced off against the Pittsburgh Penguins at Nationwide Arena, resulting in a 5-4 overtime victory for the visiting team. This outcome brought the Blue Jackets' record to 18-16-7, while the Penguins improved to 20-12-9. The game was marked by a strong start from Columbus, but Pittsburgh's resilience ultimately secured their win.


Jan 4, 2026; Columbus, Ohio, USA;  Columbus Blue Jackets goaltender Jet Greaves (73) follows the puck in play against the Pittsburgh Penguins in the second period at Nationwide Arena. Mandatory Credit: Aaron Doster-Imagn Images

First Period


The opening period saw an impressive performance from the home team as they quickly established a lead with three goals. Zach Werenski was instrumental during this period, contributing both a goal and an assist. His efforts were complemented by Dmitri Voronkov and Kirill Marchenko, who each found the back of the net to give Columbus an early advantage.


Second Period


As play resumed in the second period, Pittsburgh began to find their rhythm. The Pens managed to cut into Columbus's lead with a goal that showcased their offensive capabilities. Despite this pushback, Adam Fantilli of CBJ provided an assist that helped maintain some momentum for his team.


Jan 4, 2026; Columbus, Ohio, USA;  Columbus Blue Jackets center Charlie Coyle (3) collides with Pittsburgh Penguins goaltender Arturs Silovs (37) in the first period at Nationwide Arena. Mandatory Credit: Aaron Doster-Imagn Images

Third Period


Entering the third period with determination, Pittsburgh continued their comeback effort by scoring two more goals to level things up. The Blue Jackets struggled defensively during this stretch but remained competitive thanks largely to goaltender Jet Greaves' efforts between the pipes.


Overtime


In overtime, it was Sidney Crosby who delivered for Pittsburgh with his decisive play that sealed victory for his side. This crucial moment underscored Crosby's status as one of hockey’s elite players and left CBJ fans pondering what might have been had they capitalized on earlier opportunities.


Jan 4, 2026; Columbus, Ohio, USA;  Pittsburgh Penguins goaltender Arturs Silovs (37) makes a save in net against the Columbus Blue Jackets in the first period at Nationwide Arena. Mandatory Credit: Aaron Doster-Imagn Images

Despite falling short in overtime against their rivals from Pennsylvania’s Steel City – known affectionately among fans simply as "the Pens" – there were positives aplenty throughout much of regulation time which bodes well moving forward into future contests such as when they face San Jose Sharks next week at SAP Center on January 6th at 10:00 PM EDT; available via ESPN+, NBCS-CA or FDSOH networks respectively!


For those interested further details about how events unfolded can refer back through our comprehensive coverage including full match report detailing key turning points alongside player ratings across both rosters involved today! Share your thoughts below or spread word amongst fellow supporters eager stay informed all things related ongoing season progressions alike!

Rate the article

Related stories

Columbus Blue Jackets Electrify Nationwide Arena with Offensive Surge Against Tampa Bay Lightning
Recap

Columbus Blue Jackets Electrify Nationwide Arena with Offensive Surge Against Tampa Bay Lightning

3 min read
Columbus Blue Jackets Edge Out Dallas Stars with Defensive Masterclass at Nationwide Arena
Recap

Columbus Blue Jackets Edge Out Dallas Stars with Defensive Masterclass at Nationwide Arena

2 min read
Columbus Blue Jackets Stumble as Ottawa Senators Capitalize on Key Moments
Recap

Columbus Blue Jackets Stumble as Ottawa Senators Capitalize on Key Moments

3 min read